Updike and Out!

I have just read what is considered one of John Updike’s best novels, Rabbit Redux, the second of four telling the story of Harry (Rabbit) Angstrom’s life.  I found it to border on revolting, almost claustrophobic in its ‘conservative’ resignation to…well, almost everything, misogynistic of course, smug and obtuse about race in America – I could go on.  Updike is obviously an extremely intelligent man, and he writes beautifully, but what is style without content?  What is intelligence without critical appreciation?  Writing a novel isn’t a practical matter, just laying it all out, like engineering!  If you really want a good take-down of the man’s work, you cannot do better than the Gore Vidal in this review of Updike’s memoir and (then) latest novel.

My first exposure to Updike was Roger’s Version, which seemed little more than trash to me, but I was assured by fans that it was the very worst of this prolific writer’s output.  I had read some of his literary reviews and found them sensitive and interesting:  I’d even liked a short story and poem or two that I’d run across.  Time to give him another chance I thought.  While Rabbit Redux is a world away from Roger’s Version, the themes and content are very similar, and I’m done with Mr. Updike.

I had to grit my teeth to finish Redux, it was so deeply boring.  Harry/Rabbit understands little, questions nothing, and acts on instinct, all the while claiming to feel guilt.  I think this is how Updike seeks to portray the beautiful ordinariness of peoples’ lives.  Harry also hits his wife and the eighteen-year old rich drug addict runaway whom he takes in after his wife leaves him.  He and a loony black radical, another house guest  the one pushing dope on the girl, use her as their sex slave while they read Frederick Douglas’ autobiography to one another.  Harry also has a kid who witnesses much of this, whom Harry give beer to drink, and before whom he swears profusely and smokes pot.  He also complains the world is going to hell and that hippies have no respect for their country – go figure.

It sounds melodramatic, and maybe even interesting, but it’s all so flat, so filled with descriptions of the material minutiae of the 1960s, and the people all seem on autopilot, that it is simply excruciating.  Updike is considered a giant of the realist tradition, but to me, none of it seems real: more like the fantasy of reality imagined by an overly literary and intellectual man who is for some reason preoccupied with religion and authority.  Consider:  Harry works as a linotype operator, and comes from a working class family.  His sister goes to Hollywood to become an actress but ends up as an expensive whore.  Everyone in the family seems fine with this:  not a peep about choices, lifestyle, disappointment, anger, whatever, when she breezes home for a few days.  She and Harry chat about fucking a lot.  Just like brothers and sisters everywhere, right?  Maybe I’m naïve…

I could go on a lot about everything in this book that I didn’t like, didn’t believe, or couldn’t fathom, it was so elaborately pointless – the extended descriptions of Harry’s masturbating for example.  The lame discussions of the politics of the Vietnam War.  The constant looming of sex as a instinctual drive that seems to give no one pleasure.  The fact that neither Harry nor anybody else seems to want to try to figure out a way to do something with their lives that satisfies them.  Harry’s love for his son that seems limited to his view of him as a biological extension of himself and that certainly does not involve any care for his welfare beyond asking the drug addicts he harbors not to shoot up in front of him.  And… oh, never mind.

He sure does write sentences well, though.

5 Responses to Updike and Out!

  1. Guy Savage says:

    My opinion, and this is just a guess, is that Updike’s work does not age well.

    • Lichanos says:

      I’m not sure what that means in this case. Some people didn’t like him then, the 1960s. Hard for me to imagine that if I had been old enough, that I would have liked him then. And there are plenty of people now who think he’s the greatest. So…for whom has it not aged well? Catch my drift?

      Gore Vidal said, “At times, reading Updike’s political and cultural musings, one has the sense that Bouvard and Pecuchet must have emigrated to the United States and had many spiritual descendants.” B&P is exactly what I’m going to read next to get that awful Updikian taste out of my mouth!

  2. Ducky's here says:

    Harry/Rabbit understands little, questions nothing

    Yup, that’s Rabbit. He doesn’t change.

  3. sledpress says:

    I never could understand the enthusiasm for Updike, nor for the entire genre in which he worked: that of, as I like to call it, “people walking around and talking to each other.” When he first became a name, I was a precociously literate high schooler, and my peers were reading his books because of the gritty frankness about sex they had been led to expect. I couldn’t get through more than a few pages; I felt as if I had been locked in a stuffy little room with someone who hadn’t dry-cleaned his jacket in way too long.

    Who ever needs depictions of banal people doing banal things and not changing at all? Give me a good pulpy Rider Haggard or Stephen King — both of whom, in the process of telling stories in which stuff actually happened, also wrote some delicious sentences. (Haggard penned what may be my all-time favorite: “Never before had the depth and breadth of a naval officer’s objurgatory powers been made plain to me.” But I digress.) And both made uncomfortable statements about the ugly depths to which humans can sink and the random cruelty of the world; only, they made you care about it, like Dostoevsky, regarded as a potboiler author in his time. I don’t know when the give-a-shit factor in fiction became obsolete.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: