I like to flatter myself that I am an independent thinker, i.e, I think for myself. One of the problems with that tendency is that I sometimes find myself in disagreement with people with whom I agree most of the time. This slogan, in the button above, is one of those instances. I dislike it intensely.
The first reason I dislike it is that everyone knows that facts matter – even Trumpy and Roy Moore. Even Kelly Anne Conway, she of “alternative facts” fame. The disagreement is over what is, and what is not a fact, and how important some facts are compared to others. Science and history have their methods for resolving these questions, techniques in which our present administration is uninterested because they pose inconvenient questions, but the importance of facts is not really at issue.
One of the unpleasant aspects of being a dissenter is that you are opened up to condemnation when you disagree with the prevailing view, what Flaubert called “received wisdom.” I may agree with my friends 95% of the time, but when that 5% comes up, out comes the “Facts Matter” buttons!
The other reason I don’t like this slogan is that it presumes that the speaker has all the facts, i.e. THE FACTS. Much of the time, these days, the slogan is deployed regarding Trumpy’s lying and misstatements about politics, history, economics…well just about anything, and the newspapers, e.g. the NYTimes, are held up as proof that he is wrong. Well, I like the NYTimes and read it daily, but memory is short. About fifteen years ago, it was telling us breathless stories about the vast arsenal of weapons of mass destruction hidden in Iraq by Saddam Hussein, remember him? There were no WMDs. I knew it then, and so did lots of other people. The paper did apologize, years later, but why assume that they have the facts simply because they happen to be in the right all the time about Trumpy?
It’s a lot of work to cross check sources, read up on issues, track the positions of people to see if they lie about their past statements, and so on, but hey, you want a democracy, that’s what you have to do. You want knowledge, you have to work for it. Relying on Breitbart or the NYTimes as the oracle of The Truth is the lazy way to ignorance, though of the two, naturally you’ll do better, most of the time, with the NYTimes. That’s based on my personal research. 🙂
And just FYI, the NYTimes still maintains the same low standards of journalism they displayed in their coverage of the WMDs in Iraq when they “report” on climate science. Facts matter, but you’ll look long and hard for them in their coverage. Just sayin’. 🙂